42 replies to this topic

[IraqiWalker]

Ignoring all other discussion in this thread, as far as the OP is concerned, I don't think the HBR needs a nerf. Is it a good mech? Yes. Is it OP? No not really. It's in a decent spot, and if we can bring the other clan mechs closer to it's performance (ECM not withstanding), I think things would be solid all around for the clans.

[Onimusha shin]

i feel that the HBR needs some side torso structure quirks, something midway between those for HBKs and nothing =P

getting out traded by those IS erLL quirked boats too easily and the LT gets taken off like nothing if you're not careful when trading. some duration quirks would definitely be appreciated.

stats below. so whoever wants to whine about Clans OP is just lazy.

Clan erLL
(on HBR, 304pts armor, 44pt alpha over 3.5s, max sustained DPS: 4.68dmg/s)
(on HBR, 368pts armor, 44pt alpha over 3.5s, max sustained DPS: 4.26dmg/s)

Dmg - 11
Heat - 10
Rng - 740m
Dur'n - 1.5s
CoolD - 3.25s

IS erLL (unquirked)
Dmg - 9 (19% lower than Clan)
Heat - 8 (20% lower than Clan)
Rng - 675m (8.8% lower than Clan)
Dur'n - 1.25s (17% lower than Clan)
CoolD - 3.25s (same as Clan)

IS erLL on BLR-1S
(STD 350, 448pts armor, 36pt alpha over 2.68s (23.5% less facetime), max sustained DPS: 4.29dmg/s after quirks)
(XL 400, 480pts armor, 36pt alpha over 2.68s (23.5% less facetime), max sustained DPS: 5.29dmg/s after quirks)
Dmg - 9 (19% lower than Clan)
Heat - 7.2 (28% lower than Clan)
Rng - 844m (14% higher than Clan)
Dur'n - 1.09s (23% lower than Clan)
CoolD - 3.25s (same as Clan)

IS erLL
(quirked on TDR-5SS, 412pts armor, 36pt alpha over 3s (14.3% less facetime), max sustained DPS: 4.11dmg/s after quirks)
Dmg - 9 (19% lower than Clan)
Heat - 6.8 (32% lower than Clan)
Rng - 844m (14% higher than Clan)
Dur'n - 1.25s (17% lower than Clan)
CoolD - 2.77s (15% lower than Clan)

[Scout Derek]

With the Approach of the new Quirk system this is out the window, so closing all the threads that I made!