376 replies to this topic

[Voodoomancer]

The new Jade Falcon logo is definitely better, but for the others I would go with the classic versions. The new Bear looks kinda flabby; Wolf looks like he just noticed something nasty on the floor (the snarl doesn't reach his eyes), and the Jaguar looks like he just realized he's leaping at a porcupine.

Harsh, I know.... but that's the way I saw it.

[StandingInFire]

Spoiler

Nikolai Lubkiewicz, on 10 June 2014 - 10:53 AM, said:

Bear: Traditional is far better then new, no question on that one.
Traditional: 1 New: 0
Falcon: New is far better then traditional, no question on that one.
Traditional: 1 New: 1
Wolf: Old is simplified better for icons/flags, but I prefer the color scheme of the new one a lot, the old one looks like its been in the laundry to many times.
Traditional: 2 (with 1 recolor) New: 1
Jaguar: Old looks like a derpy cat, new just needs smoke color on the jaguar.
Traditional: 2 (with 1 recolor) New: 2 (with 1 recolor)

So I voted new, because its really a tie in quality imo.

[Bigg Robb]

Traditional.

[xengk]

Not a Clanner, but Im torn between the 2 designs.
I prefer the Classic Ghost Bear and Smoke Jaguar, but the modern Jade Falcon and Clan Wolf is more appealing to me.

[Jetfire]

The classic proposals look like MW. The new ones simply look too much like they were designed for a modern hockey team. They didn't carry over the feel as well as they could have.

[Ragedog4]

May I just say I do like how Jade F. Looks in the new. Who ever created the new ones you did a good job in the way of art, dont take this the wrong way from some/a lot of us. We are remembering years of the same logos and it is hard to change that. We are not saying your creations are terrible, we are saying we like our classic memories.

Another note, I do love the classics, just give some good coloring to them. No major changes, just some changes on the color from light to dark giving a nice rich feel to them while still keeping the classic look. Thanks.

[Flying Fox 333]

Am torn as well. I think overall the new ones are definitely better though.

Love the Wolf and Jade Falcon ones. I would like to see a change to the reimagined Jaguar's fill pattern to that of the classic smokey one and make its eyes yellow to match the teeth and claws. I actually prefer the classic Ghost Bear logo over the reimagined, as the symmetry is better and the bear is more identifiable.

[Wispsy]

So basically everybody is voting classic because CGB is terrible

Old CJF sooo terrible!

[Aresye]

Classic logos all the way!

Love the enthusiasm behind the redesigns, but they just strayed too far from the originals.

[PASHA]

Classic emblems. Thank you, PGI.

[Masterzinja]

Eh, while the old jade falcon looks a little plump, the new one looks like a cartoon sparrow. Since I'm asked to choose I'd rather stick with classic.

[Xyroc]

new look a lot better.

[Modo44]

Perilthecat, on 10 June 2014 - 04:39 PM, said:

Just goes to show that no matter what you do someone is always going to whine about it.

Many problems in the game -- including art inconsistency, e.g. map bugs or mech looks -- are more than a year old, and the list appears to be growing, not shrinking. But hey, work the ******* logos instead, 'cause you "listen to the players".

[Thorqemada]

I will not Vote but i like 2 of each:
Classic Ghost Bear and Wolf (Wolf is a tad light coloured though).
Reimagined Jade Falcon and Jaguar (albeit Jaguar misses the "Smoke").

[EnegueWeil]

Classic thank you

[Thoman Coston]

New jade Falcon, classic everything else. 3:1 classic.

[El Bandito]

I voted classic, and I am glad that 3/4 of the player base are keeping it real.

Edited by El Bandito, 10 June 2014 - 07:38 PM.

[Xoxim SC]

The new Falcon looks amazing in comparison to the old imo. And don't get me started on that goofy Jaguar, can we just get rid of that clan entirely? Classic wolf looks awesome, but so does the new one, minus the stars being empty. And of course the classic Ghost Bear looks way better than the retouch.

[Bernard Matthaios]

Taigen, on 10 June 2014 - 07:32 PM, said:

New jade Falcon, classic everything else. 3:1 classic.

My thoughts exactly.

[Ecrof]

Why not keep both? Why limit cosmetic choices?