27 replies to this topic

[Strayed]

who'd win in a fight? Kai, Phalen, or Minoru?

[Grayson Pryde]

I think Phelan is the bigger MarySue. Imean come on just think about his live.

1. He got kicked out of "Nagelring" because he had done everything right
2. Saved his Company and got caught by the clans (but not without making Vlad angry)
3. Was taken bondsman by the Khan himself
4.Meet with Präzentor Martialum and impressed him.
6. Kicked Evanthas and Vlads *** at the same time.
5. Saved the Khan + Vlad fom the bridge because he can.
7. Got introduced into the warrior caste. (Lincoln Osis spoke for the elementals).
8. Best friend of the new Il-Khan Kerensky
9. Made his trial of position with Natasha Kerensky(his old dragoon girlfirend and new Khan)
10. Conquered a world just with some leather clothes and a mask(but refused the sunglasses because it would look too cool!)
11. Made the prince of Raselhagg his bondsman
12. He got a bloodname under bad sircumstances(always had to fight as the underdog and still win)
13. surprise-> shortly after his Bloodname (where Conal Ward cheatet) he was made saKhan under Natascha Kerensky
14. As a present to his homie, Ulrics last order was that Kell is now a Bloodname
15. Phelan took the Warden Wolf Clanpart to his parents in the Inner Sphere and they all stayed happily on Ark Royal.
16. The Prince of the FedCom and the Archon of the Lyran Alliance are his cousins.(i wonder why he has no conections to Liao and Marik too)

I dont know anymore if i took everything in the right order but yeah Phelan is the biggest Mary Sue in Battletech. Kai Allard seems to be normal against him.

Edited by Grayson Pryde, 21 November 2011 - 04:14 PM.

[SquareSphere]

A Kai v Phelan would be the best path to peace (at least for a day), i mean the Jade Falcon already basically freaking love Kai. If he fought the Khan of clan wolf, I pretty sure the JF would halt all invasion plan just so they could watch the PPV.

[Yeach]

They had a Kai vs Phelan battle in the novel "Natural Selection".
I believe they both killed each other; in simulation only.

[Creel]

Grayson Pryde, on 21 November 2011 - 04:12 PM, said:

16. The Prince of the FedCom and the Archon of the Lyran Alliance are his cousins.(i wonder why he has no conections to Liao and Marik too)

http://www.sarna.net...Kai_Allard-Liao

Apparently, you didn't notice his last name. He's sun tzu's first cousin. He was also pretty close to Isis Marik during the fedcom civil war.

Edited by Creel, 22 November 2011 - 12:53 AM.

[EDMW CSN]

Morgan Kell has Phantom Mech Ability, does that carry on to Phelan ?

[CaveMan]

[EDMW]CSN, on 22 November 2011 - 01:12 AM, said:

Morgan Kell has Phantom Mech Ability, does that carry on to Phelan ?

I don't think that was genetic, more of a mystical thing. Remember Morgan Kell spent years in a monastery.

[Grayson Pryde]

Creel, on 22 November 2011 - 12:52 AM, said:

http://www.sarna.net...Kai_Allard-Liao

Apparently, you didn't notice his last name. He's sun tzu's first cousin. He was also pretty close to Isis Marik during the fedcom civil war.

I talked about Phelan Kell not Kai.