I'm using a RVN-H, CPLT-K2, AWS-8Q and RVN-3L (with MLs and SRM4's). Hellbringers, Stormcrows, Timber Wolves. They're all being mowed down like everyone else. Just like the public matches we're used to.
Now, I'm sure the elite units have a significant advantage against other elite units using Tier 1 Clan mechs. Because at the very top, the competition is fierce and there may not be such a huge skill disparity between winners and losers. But there's a very chunky portion of the bell curve with lots of fairly casual and average players, where the level of skill varies tremendously. In most matches, you don't have to use a Timber Wolf to stay competitive.
I just got out of a match with 9 kills and 2 remaining mechs. I didn't carry the team, but overall our team was more skilled. Others did more damage than me, but the point is, our ragged company of Cicadas, Hunchbacks, Stalkers and Orions put the hurt on those Tier 1 Clan mechs like nobody's business.
Note: PUG vs 11 man group.
EDIT: There's also the possibility that the enemy just made some tactical errors because they're not familiar with the map or game mode, and that things will change when everyone has familiarised themselves. There's also the possibility that the maps are not balanced and defending is a lot easier than attacking. I mostly started this thread to brag about my 9 kills, to be honest.
Edited by Alistair Winter, 11 December 2014 - 04:23 PM.