Lily from animove, on 26 June 2014 - 10:48 PM, said:
No, because the atlas is fast enough to stay outside their range carefully boiling the canned food with his lasers.
Well, if we're talking about a TT stock AS7-D against say, four TT stock UM-R60s, then it's going to be a close fight.
The Atlas has a speed advantage and a LRM-20, but the rest of its weapons are shorter-ranged than the AC/10 on the Urbies. Ideally, the Urbies would try to stay 271+ meters away and spread out; 4xAC/10 will kill the Atlas before 1xLRM-20 can kill four Urbies.
The Atlas, on the other hand, would want to close to less than 270 meters on the Urbies one by one; giving them a taste of AC/20, SRM-6, and 4xML as often as possible. Shouldn't take more than one or two of those "alphas" to take an Urbie out of commission, and every one down means taking less return fire as well.
In the end though, it all depends on the skill of the pilots and the battlefield layout. It's not a foregone conclusion that the Atlas would actually win.