53 replies to this topic

[Joseph Mallan]

Deathlike, on 12 May 2014 - 01:25 PM, said:

Boo, I'll have to send you back to Mordor with teh precious!

Forest Colony [b]50[/b] 27 23 1.17 04:49:25
Frozen City [i][b]49[/b][/i] 28 21 1.33 04:16:43
Caustic Valley 110 59 51 1.16 11:17:16
River City [u][i]57[/i][/u] 32 25 1.28 05:54:54
Forest Colony Snow [b]62[/b] 35 26 1.35 06:24:11
Frozen City Night [i][b]54[/b][/i] 31 23 1.35 04:29:24
River City Night [u][i]46[/i][/u] 28 18 1.56 04:48:22
Alpine Peaks 104 65 39 1.67 12:52:22
Tourmaline Desert 107 65 41 1.59 10:44:50
Canyon Network 103 59 43 1.37 10:51:48
Terra Therma 114 65 48 1.35 12:32:58
Crimson Strait 92 45 47 0.96 09:35:04
HPG Manifold 98 57 41 1.39 09:46:17

Yet, Mordor wins...

It wins by 2 drops over both Forest Colony maps (112 combined)
11 Drops over River City Combined maps.
13 more drops than on Frozen City Maps.

[Blood Rose]

Terra-*******-Therma as well I really really REALLY hate that map.

[Cimarb]

Blood Rose, on 14 May 2014 - 05:50 AM, said:

Terra-*******-Therma as well I really really REALLY hate that map.

How is your win percent, though? I was quite surprised that Terra Therma was my highest winning map by a decent margin as well as most common.

[Bilbo]

Cimarb, on 14 May 2014 - 06:22 AM, said:

How is your win percent, though? I was quite surprised that Terra Therma was my highest winning map by a decent margin as well as most common.

HPG and River City Night are my best by a mile. everything else hovers either side of 1.

[mogs01gt]

Canyon Network 40
Terra Therma 37

I dont mind Canyon but hate TT.

[Cimarb]

Bilbo, on 14 May 2014 - 06:25 AM, said:

HPG and River City Night are my best by a mile. everything else hovers either side of 1.

HPG is my second highest at 1.61, and my worst is Frozen City Night at 0.8. Terra Therma, for all the complaining I do about it, seems to treat me very well at 1.77 - sure doesn't feel like I win that often on it, though...

[Lunaya]

You can view your own here

https://mwomercs.com.../stats?type=map

Some maps do seem to show up a lot more than others, sadly my favorite is one of the least

Edited by Pasternak, 14 May 2014 - 06:51 AM.

[Bilbo]

Cimarb, on 14 May 2014 - 06:40 AM, said:

HPG is my second highest at 1.61, and my worst is Frozen City Night at 0.8. Terra Therma, for all the complaining I do about it, seems to treat me very well at 1.77 - sure doesn't feel like I win that often on it, though...

The map doesn't suit my Atlas. I just wish I could change mechs based off the given map. I'd never willingly take my Atlas there. I imagine that is why many don't like the map. They just wouldn't take their favored mech there.

[Durandal]

Edit, table fail



So Crimson and Manifold beat out TT for me, but all three hot maps are right at that 80 point. Frozen City Day/Night combined are less, but Forest Colony normal/frozen combined are about the same mid 80's average. It does make me wonder if Frozen City/Forest Colony have their variants combined for number of plays to keep them even with the other maps.

I would like to see Canyon more though...I really enjoy that map...

Looking back at my archived stats, it's very similar...most maps are about equal, but the one I see least is Frozen City, followed by Forest Colony (both variants combined)

Edited by durandal, 14 May 2014 - 06:57 AM.

[Cimarb]

Pasternak, on 14 May 2014 - 06:45 AM, said:

You can view your own here

https://mwomercs.com.../stats?type=map

Some maps do seem to show up a lot more than others, sadly my favorite is one of the least

Notice how Terra Therma is your highest WLR, though. Same as mine. It is also 6th place for durandal, which isn't too bad.

Bilbo, I'm curious what your stats for it look like. Like I was saying, I'm just as unhappy to see that map as most other people, but it is all perception, because it seems to be a pretty "winning" map for a lot of us despite our dislike of it.

[Bilbo]

Cimarb, on 14 May 2014 - 07:30 AM, said:

Notice how Terra Therma is your highest WLR, though. Same as mine. It is also 6th place for durandal, which isn't too bad.

Bilbo, I'm curious what your stats for it look like. Like I was saying, I'm just as unhappy to see that map as most other people, but it is all perception, because it seems to be a pretty "winning" map for a lot of us despite our dislike of it.

Terra Therma 93 45 47 0.96 08:39:18

[Lancer Deistler]

Just out of curiosity, has "SimplyWalksIntoMordor has killed Bilbo" ever happened on terra therma?

[crossflip]

Maps with variants (snow/night) have their frequency halved to compensate for their similarity, but aside from that it's entirely random. I've played conquest on CN over 50 times but on Alpine I've only played 14.

[Bilbo]

Lancer Deistler, on 14 May 2014 - 07:39 AM, said:

Just out of curiosity, has "SimplyWalksIntoMordor has killed Bilbo" ever happened on terra therma?

No... But I'd giggle like a little girl if it ever happened.

[BOWMANGR]

I agree Terra Therma play frequency was REALLY bad the week it got introduced and although it seems they "fixed" it, it still appears a lot more than it should be.

My archived stats show that Terra Therma is by far my most played map but also my current stats {which don't include the high frequency week obviously} still have Terra Therma at the top although by a smaller margin.


I hate that map by the way. The mountains are too big to make flanking maneuvers viable, cover is limited. The new spawnpoints fixed it somewhat for me because you no longer need to walk 5 minutes to shoot someone for 2 minutes as before but still no tactics to be found. It's just a shooting gallery with random winners. {although now that the matchmaker is borked, EVERY map is a random winner shooting gallery with the illusion of strategy. Most matches are pre-decided by the matchmaker as it is.}


P.S. FIX the damned matchmaker!

Edited by BOWMANGR, 14 May 2014 - 07:49 AM.

[Hillslam]

Who cares if you're winning or losing on a map if you're not having fun?

For me, the craptastic TT is middle of the pack, but that sumb1ch would be number 1 if I didn't have a strange crash to desktop bug nearly everytime I drop on it. It is still number 3 in terms of hours played though, regardless. Meaning, when I DO drop on it, I spend a lot of time on it. And I know just where this is spent: everyone crawling around the skateboard-halfpipe rat maze looking for each other, uphill the whole way, while the lights WEEE WEEE their way around the hillocks like dirt bike track moguls.
Fun.

Not.

God help that pile of an abortion of PGI ever stops being stubborn and gives us a map filter. I will never willingly drop on that pos again.

PS - PGI never fix my bug please

PPS - its all a conspiracy: you know dang well the private matchers are never picking TT, leaving us public scrubs to dump on that used tampon all the more often.

[Jody Von Jedi]

Crimson Strait is my most played map, but just barely. Top 5 below.

Map matches W/L ratio
Crimson Strait 83 1.10
Terra Therma 79 1.55
HPG Manifold 76 1.59
Tourmaline Desert 73 1.35
Caustic Valley 73 1.03

My least favorite map is Forest Colony, it's way too small. Ratio is .66
No wonder it's my least favorite.


Jody

[Deathlike]

Joseph Mallan, on 14 May 2014 - 05:42 AM, said:

It wins by 2 drops over both Forest Colony maps (112 combined)
11 Drops over River City Combined maps.
13 more drops than on Frozen City Maps.

It doesn't matter... what matters is Mordor is on top.

I hate Alpine, but it's also my highest winning percentage... due to mindless droning (fish in a barrel usually when you tell people how to win it).

Edited by Deathlike, 14 May 2014 - 08:09 AM.

[Cimarb]

Bilbo, on 14 May 2014 - 07:33 AM, said:

Terra Therma 93 45 47 0.96 08:39:18

How does that compare to your other maps, though? Higher, lower, about the middle of the pack? Not needing exact numbers, but so far everyone that has provided them is on the "winning side" for that particular map despite their distaste for it, which is surprising.

Jody Von Jedi, on 14 May 2014 - 07:49 AM, said:

Crimson Strait is my most played map, but just barely. Top 5 below.

Map matches W/L ratio
Crimson Strait 83 1.10
Terra Therma 79 1.55
HPG Manifold 76 1.59
Tourmaline Desert 73 1.35
Caustic Valley 73 1.03

My least favorite map is Forest Colony, it's way too small. Ratio is .66
No wonder it's my least favorite.

Jody

Again, though, Mordor is one of your most successful maps... How odd... For every win, there is a loss, yet I haven't saw anyone with nearly as significant of a loss ratio as we all have winning... Imagine how those people feel about the map!

I have to agree about Forest Colony. I play Skirmish almost exclusively, which is the most preferable game mode for that dinky little map, and it's still one of my least favorite (with frozen city likely lowest on my "like" list... Stupid brawler towns....)

Edited by Cimarb, 14 May 2014 - 08:27 AM.

[Bilbo]

Cimarb, on 14 May 2014 - 08:17 AM, said:

How does that compare to your other maps, though? Higher, lower, about the middle of the pack? Not needing exact numbers, but so far everyone that has provided them is on the "winning side" for that particular map despite their distaste for it, which is surprising.


Again, though, Mordor is on elf your most successful maps... How odd... For every win, there is a loss, yet I haven't saw anyone with nearly as significant of a loss ratio as we all have winning... Imagine how those people feel about the map!

I have to agree about Forest Colony. I play Skirmish almost exclusively, which is the most preferable game mode for that dinky little map, and it's still one of my least favorite (with frozen city likely lowest on my "like" list... Stupid brawler towns....)

Average.
Forest Colony 61 27 33 0.82 03:45:06
Frozen City 51 23 28 0.82 03:23:46
Caustic Valley 108 52 56 0.93 07:36:58
River City 56 28 28 1.00 03:24:04
Forest Colony Snow 51 27 24 1.13 03:35:41
Frozen City Night 62 27 34 0.79 04:24:10
River City Night 51 30 21 1.43 03:35:42
Alpine Peaks 93 40 53 0.75 09:26:11
Tourmaline Desert 105 59 46 1.28 07:52:48
Canyon Network 103 53 50 1.06 07:49:32
Terra Therma 93 45 47 0.96 08:39:18
Crimson Strait 111 54 56 0.96 08:28:09
HPG Manifold 126 76 49 1.55 09:11:48