376 replies to this topic

[ATao]

Classic.

Falcon's beak is too big though. Should be like ~25% smaller.

Edited by Alexander Malthus, 10 June 2014 - 12:35 PM.

[Waylandx]

I Voted! You should to!

[CandidAstrius]

just can't get behind the "Re-imagined", maybe if the wolf didn't look like it was caught mid sneeze, the smoke jaguar was still smokey, and the bear wasn't taking a crap in the woods... do like the JF... but if it's all or nothing bring on the parrot.

[Odanan]

Nikolai Lubkiewicz, on 10 June 2014 - 10:53 AM, said:

Greetings MechWarriors,

As you may have previously heard, a hot debate grew out of the initial release of the Clan logos. We are happy to announce today that we have finalized a second batch of logos for your consideration.

The first column presents the proposed classic logos. The second column presents the current re-imagined emblems.

------------------Proposed----------------------------------------Current--------------------
-------------Classic / Traditional----------------------Modern / Re-imagined------------


While there are aesthetic benefits to each design, it is ultimately you MechWarriors who be wearing and seeing these colours in action: We leave it in your hands to decide whether we stand with the modern or the traditional design.

Please note, in the circumstance that the Proposed design is the winner of this poll, be aware that release of the new design in-game has an ETA for the next available patch, and similar changes to in-game cockpit items included with the Clan Collections further down the line.

Yes! Yes! Yes!

[Omaximus Tseng]

I voted classic, although the new ones are nice and modern. Why not just put both in the game and add some new designs for the IS? That way people can choose what they want. Everybody's happy

[Chemistrius]

Classic just for GB

[CoffiNail]

I think these votes run parallel to the thread I had a couple days ago in feature suggestions. Three quarters of the votes are for classic refresh one quarter for modern.

Thread closed. Can we have classic as forum icons now? I can stop being Clan sneezy/drunk Bear.

[One of Little Harmony]

My biggest question is: what does it look like as an icon?

I voted reimagined, because they look better except for CGB. Ghost Bear's one is just.... uh... lol

Edited by One of Little Harmony, 10 June 2014 - 12:49 PM.

[Sable]

Ghost Bear - Classic
Decades go by but its still the best.

Jade Falcon - Modern
The new one just looks so much more edgy and sharp.

Clan Wolf - Classic
The eyes on the new one just make it look odd. The blind eyes of fanatism in the classic wolf looks much more appropriate.

Smoke Jaguar - uh.. modern design but with the classic smokey color
The grey color looks better from the classic but i like the new design angle with its sharp colors.

Edited by Sable, 10 June 2014 - 12:50 PM.

[Ozy Hunter]

Great... we get stuck with a fat pigeon... the New Redesigns are much classier... if only people aren't always getting stuck in the past...

[Malcolm Vordermark]

Voted classic. Something about them just feels right.

Thank you for going through all this trouble. It seems small but it is something very important to some of us.

Edited by Rouken, 10 June 2014 - 12:50 PM.

[Suicidal Baby]

The problem I have is that while I like most of the new ones, Ghost Bear is just so bad that I have to vote classic.

Bear - keep the old lines with the new color and shading. Don't reposition the head.
Jade - Keep the new one, worlds better than old.
Wolf - lines and color are welcomed, lose the details.
Jaguar - lose the orange, make it smoke grey. Tone it down.

Edited by Suicidal Baby, 10 June 2014 - 12:52 PM.

[Oethe]

Hell yes to the proposed/classic. Those are awesome.

I still admit I like the new Jade Falcon. Ghsot Bear and Wolf Proposed are so much better though.

Edited by Oethe, 10 June 2014 - 12:55 PM.

[ArcDemon]

All 4 look much better. The Wolf and Jade Falcon in particular are massive improvements and I think are actually a bit better then the reference design (FASA) for use in a game like MWO. While Smoke Jaguar is a big improvement (it's now an actual smoke jaguar instead of random black kitty) I'll have to reserve complete judgement until I can see the in game little icons.

The only one I really don't entirely like is Ghost Bear. Again I think the proposed ('classic look') design is much better but I still don't agree with one change that was made in both, placing the design off center. The Ghost Bear flag is meant to have the bear paw 'spokes' radiating out on all sides in a kind of symmetry. Cutting off half the design not only harms it in the large version, it removes the chief trait by which it can be recognized when in icon form. I know it needs to be cropped slightly (to aid in making it icon size and to match the others) but I think it would work better with symmetrical cropping where all sides are cut off equally. The Wolf flag already uses somewhat symmetrical cropping.

Edited by ArcDemon, 10 June 2014 - 01:00 PM.

[Lucian Nostra]

by and far the tradiional ones

[BLOOD1975]

cant we mix it?

ghostbear & smoke jaguar:
new logo

wolf & jadefalcon:
classic style

[Raigner]

give me a more modernized smoke jag and jade falcon those old emblems look terrible even with the slight touch up, but wolf and ghost bear look great, can we just vote on that?

[CoffiNail]

So, Umm... Obviously classic logos. Any chance we can get a good quality, non flag, full logo?

[WhoDidTheElf]

Scoots, on 10 June 2014 - 11:49 AM, said:

Torn...
Old Ghost Bear
New Jade Falcon
Old Wolf
New Smoke Jaguar

The new Ghost Bear and Wolf Logos look kinda too detailed and therefore out of style.
The new Jade Falcon is just awesome and the Smoke Jaguar doesn't look like a drawing of a five year old anymore.

This is my exact feeling on it.

[Citizen Erased]

I seriously think that the modern ones are great. But the old ones have a minimalist style that fit better.

Can't decide