No replies to this topic

[Mawai]

Dear PGI,

The forums have been full of anecdotal reports on winning vs losing on the various maps with various configurations of IS vs clan.

In particular, many feel that it is difficult for the attacker to win.

I don't know that this is the case. I have been involved in two matches with clans attacking and IS defending. In one the clans won while in the second they damaged the base to 50%. The difference in the loss was that the attack was less coordinated and too many clan mechs were wasted in sorties with one or two that were easily stopped. If the clans in the second match had pressed with a couple of waves of 10 to 12 that focused on taking out the base and ignored defenders they likely would have won.

On the other hand, the other match I was in with IS attacking and clan defending on the two gate map ... was pretty much a lost cause. We didn't manage to damage the base and although we did eliminate 27 clan mechs it wasn't nearly enough. The IS just didn't have the speed and dps to push through to the base and win on a rush.

So ,, in order to get an idea of how the balance actually is ... can we get some statistics please?

Win/loss numbers for clan vs is, clan vs clan, is vs is, in both attack and defend roles on both maps.