Imperius, on 20 May 2017 - 04:03 PM, said:
Dude have you ever gone positive? I think the pilot is the issue in your balance issues! Season 6 is your only time to go positive...
I generally agree with you in that Requiemking exaggerates the weaknesses of the Mad Cat MKII in MWO, and downplays its importance in the lore. (Just like you do the opposite, if you don't mind me saying so).
However arguing ad personam is not the way to go. We need to be level-headed especially in the assessment of fan favourites. I mean be happy, and if you don't want a back and forth about the expectations on the Mech's performance, just leave it be. ...and prove the Mech's worth in the field.
I am still sure it will be a fine assault Mech. Nowhere near the best the Clans have to offer, but strong nonetheless. As far as engine decoupling is concerned, you have to count yourself lucky you won't have to drive the Annihilator.
Sereglach, on 20 May 2017 - 01:29 PM, said:
PGI, also, is likely to take the most popular or most well known pilot of any given hero option, rather than a more obscure hero that's more "era appropriate" (not saying that's true in the Assassin's case, just letting you know) which means 3rd and 4th succession war hero options are the more likely candidates for any mech available in that timeframe . . . since that's where more nostalgia lies.
That sounds about right, in theory. However I seriously doubt the great popularity of pilots who have only an obscure TRO-entry like Wilkes. I have not seen the masses of Wilkes-fans demanding his Mech. And those few who knew Wilkes at all usually know the other notable Javelin-pilots too, since they have just the same kind of obscure TRO-entry.
In the end, it all seems rather convenient; just take a name, make up a Mech, and canon be damned. It means losing a lot of flavour, since it effectively reduces the Hero Mech to another special Mech variant without deeper meaning beyond the MC price tag.
Of course, if the community is happy with that I can hardly change it. Does not mean I have to like it, and certainly it does not show great love for the franchise or its lore.
Edit: if the forum's search engine and google's search engine are accurate, the name of Wilkes was brought up once on the forum. Once. In many years. Hardly a fan favourite.
Edited by FLG 01, 20 May 2017 - 05:55 PM.