I think if they was to do something like this they need to have a third option which would be Merc only.
as to the other games they mentioned I think is down right foolish to use them as an example.
Battletech & Mech warrior are so much more than just those garbage games that don't do justice to their lore(at least in st case).
but as I said on other pages, all factions can get access to all mechs in some form or another, hell even Herb at one point stated(a long time ago) that any faction can have access to all tech it would just cost more or be even harder to get.
now let's also look at canon factions. Diamond Sharks(their other name is stupid and cannot believe they would change their name) are well known for selling clan tech be it mechs or weapon systems to those in the Inner Sphere willing to pay for it.
So that there throws out anyone trying to keep players from using all tech under one pilot tab.
also by all rights, Clan players should be able to use IS mechs like the Commando, Locust, Jenners and others as they had a ton of them mothballed which they pulled out later on to help fill out their ranks.
or am I forgetting something as it has been a while.
only way for this to work for players with two pilots is like this:
Pilot 1 would have access to the mechs bought for that tab regardless of tech type
for example Pilot would have
1 Thunderbolt
1 Adder
while tab 2 would have for example:
1 Atlas
1 Shadow Hawk
for these two examples
Tab 1 would not have access to Tab 2's mechs and vice versa.
that is the only way I see it working.
Edited by VinJade, 08 September 2015 - 10:15 PM.