@ JT
I think you have partially stumbled on to MercStar's secret plans for Season 2 of CW. But first I will clear up a few of your points.
1. Falcons have indeed been fairly consistent throughout CW. But, depending on what your definition of consistent is, I would argue that Wolf is equally or more consistent. Falcon loyalist units that are noteworthy really only consist of KCOM and JFP, the rest tend to be Mercs (VRGD likely being the most prominent). Wolf though has the big 3 of CWI, SWOL, and CWDG as well as a few other decent loyalist units, as well as a goodly number of impressive Merc units that are in the area from time to time (-MS-, CI, + others). I think the reason Falcon looks stronger than Wolf to some people is the fact that Falcon only ever really has 1 IS lane, while Wolf has ranged from 2-3 for most of its life. Falcon fights its back and forth war, while Wolf either expands or shrinks, depending on where -MS- and CI are, as well as whether or not they are being hammered on all sides by nearly the full might of the IS.
2. Edit was for a typo. On the note of Q times, -MS- still practically insta drops most matches. Wait times are in the very acceptable range. As long as we fight Clan vs IS, the call to arms finds us a match 98% of the time. What we are looking for, is more games against strong, organized opponents. After the first 5 days of season 2, I knew that something needed to change. So I came up with a plan. A mighty plan that likely only MercStar could achieve. A plan that I hoped would bring some semblance of life back to the front lines of CW.
3. From your text, I am assuming you are implying -MS- is what has created the imbalance in CW. I suppose there is an argument for that. Much in the same way that SJR, EmP, Lords, and even SwK at a time, created a significant imbalance in competitive MWO. Simply put, there are very few team that can compete against those team at that high end level of play.
The same can be said about CW. -MS- the unit was created only 2 days before the start of CW, with the express interest in playing CW at a competitive level. We put our all into it. We play everyday, in all 3 phases. We recruit players, train them, get them in proper Tier 1 or 2 mechs, and give them the tools and support to thrive in CW. Hell, the only reason I really support -MS- fielding 2 (soon to be 3) 24 man competitive teams, is because comp play is amazing at teaching players the skills and comms and mechs that are needed to excel at robots in general, as well as CW.
So, does -MS- create an imbalance in CW? Quite possibly. Is it MercStar's responsibility to stop playing CW/handicap itself/disband into multiple units/generally be less awesome? Hell no. Would you ask that of (insert top sports team here)? Not likely. The reality is PGI needs to find a way to get people interested in CW again. I think having planet ownership actually do something would be a huge step. Nothing gets people interested like a profit motive. Even MercStar is seeing a slump in daily player numbers. we only average a pair of 12 mans at best these days. But apparently that is about 2 more 12 mans than anyone else is fielding. Heck, we destroyed CSJ and CGB with only 1 dedicated 12 man per night. we only ever had the second 12 man going for an hour or two at most on any nights, and certainly not every day.
So I guess at the end of the day, my point is this: If 24 or less pilots at any given time are enough to cripplingly unbalance CW, than CW is screwed and we all may as well find another game to play. Many people put the blame on MercStar for that. I say it is the other 99% of the community that is letting CW down. Where are the mighty legions of TCAF, Kurita High Command, the Free Worlds League ts server, and all the other organized conglomerates? Even most of the better Comp CW units, like 228th, QQ, AS, etc have been largely absent from this season of CW.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
MercStar's Super Secret Plan to Save CW has entered phase 2!
Phase 1: go out of our way to effectively destroy/remove a number of northern factions from CW.
We did this over the course of 9 days, while under paid contract from employers in Kurita. We took out CSJ and CGB almost entirely, which in turn removed all Clan attack lanes for Kurita. The goal of this two stage move was to "encourage" (through either destruction or lack of available attack lanes) most units away from those 3 factions, towards the western factions of Wolf, Falcon, FRR, and Steiner.
It was also hoped that any useful southern units would migrate North West due to a complete lack of anything to do down south.
The end result being, that we shift all available and participating CW units over to a reduced front line, involving only 4 of the 10 factions. This in turn would at least bolster pop numbers to the point where we could have a decent war involving most of the CW population.
This would appear to be working quite well actually. units are leaving HK, CGB, CSJ as expected. 9thSD went Falcon (Im pretty sure) NKVA went Steiner, NS is rumoured to be going FRR, if they havn't already. BSK went Falcon. Im sure some smoke Jag units have moved on. QQ left Kurita for FRR, then went Falcon. And the list goes on and on.
So far, the only real exceptions to this plans full success are fairly minor. I'm told Davion High Command actually went out and hired some Mercs of their own to stop the Kurita agression on their border (good on them btw, great to see them getting more involved in CW politics) the big names here are 228th, the Serephim, Cameron's Highlanders and a few others, though I cannot confirm which units are actually being paid to go there, and which simply chose to for other reasons. Antares Scorpions went Liao for some reason (I'd assume for the mechbay) and TCAF finally left their southern base in Liao and decided to try and fight real people up on the clan borders. Unfortunately for TCAF, their leadership picked the wrong friggin place to go, as they showed up 1 day after MercStar wiped out all of Kurita's Clan opponents. Now all TCAF has to do is ghost drop against Davion from the North rather than the South lol. I hope they didnt take a very long contract, cuz that was obviously the wrong choice
Anyways, to wrap this up, MercStar's plans are going pretty good. We are trying to do our part to help CW, and I feel we are doing a pretty damn good job of it. Simply put, no unit other than MercStar is apparently capable of accomplishing what we did (though, it only took our less than 2 12 mans 9 days to do it). I hope that things continue to shift this way, with every unit and their mother heading to the North Western 4 factions. Once this happens in full, we can have a good old brawl for a month or two until PGI resets things and we start on season 3. Hopefully with planet tags meaning something, a ton of new features, and a return of the populace to CW.
Thus Spoke MercStar.