FupDup, on 17 September 2015 - 05:33 PM, said:
Are you really accusing the TREBUCHET of all mechs of having too powerful quirks?
Yes, I am. You've proven yourself able to read and comprehend.
I will explain what I mean:
The Trebuchet has always been, and should be, a *missile*-centric mech, preferable Long Range Missiles.
Prior to quirks, it served as a decent 50 ton missile-toter. The reason you don't see many of them now is the same you don't see many missile boats anymore altogether: ECM has earned its nickname of "Jesus Box", it's become more common with almost every wave of new 'Mechs being released, and it's extremely difficult to take a missile loadout & the necessary anti-ECM equipment (BAP and TAG, minimum, imo) on a 50 ton 'Mech and still be able to carry enough missile tubes & ammunition for them to be effective.
My Founder's Catapult barely gets by, and it has
15 more tons to play with than the Trebuchet does.
The fact that other 'Mechs are leaps and bounds ahead of the Trebuchet solely thanks to Power Ranger Super Quirks ™ only makes the problem worse.
If you want to see more Trebuchets in the game, here's the steps you take:
1. Remove all weapon quirks
2. Complete the "balance pass" in full, including equipment (specifically for ECM, bringing it down to MW4:Mercs/MW:LL levels of utility)
3. Switch LRMs from being focused on indirect support by making them faster and more accurate (or at least same accuracy across all types of launchers that can only be increased with Artemis), but requiring more accuracy with the aiming reticule (no more waving the reticule over the target repeatedly for mere moments and calling it good). This, in combination with the information warfare changes that will happen - an early "alpha" version of which exists on the current PTS - will I think make missiles useful in a new way without being overpowering.
Certainly, that particular Trebuchet build will play more like a Hunchback or 50-ton Shadowhawk than a true Trebuchet, but that's what makes having variants of a 'Mech chassis fun - variety.
Edited by Telmasa, 17 September 2015 - 07:51 PM.