Aegis Kleais™, on 11 March 2012 - 03:25 PM, said:
I think it's equal parts the perfectionist in me as it is a generational thing. I tried to boil it all down to the basic reason, and I honestly think it is the repetition. Like a person at work who thinks they're funny, and they've told you the same joke over and over, but they're expecting a laugh out of you each time. It's like a painful silence, where you're left looking at them with an expression of "Honestly?!? Do you NOT realize this has been said umpteen billion times before?!" lol.
But I guess those people I classified as lemmings either have REALLY bad memory, or they find repetition to be very funny. I guess to each their own.
Or they could genuinely not have encountered a particular "meme" before. The 'Net is a big place, and nobody can read everything there is on it, so what may be old hat for you, is to another new and refreshing.
For example, I first encountered the phrase "morally justified" used in a debate on a fictional character's action, and I took a liking to it. A few weeks later, I had the opportunity to use it myself, and I got a response of something like, "Groan. Let's not bring that old canard from the OOTS forum here, okay?" The funny thing is that I had no idea what an OOTS was at the time, so I was completely confused by the reference. Fortunately, the abbreviation is easily googled, and the Order of the Stick is now one of my favorite webcomics.