Mezlo Mezzerak, on 21 February 2013 - 11:27 AM, said:
Sayla all Trothkin
Just a quick statement from me:
Is it so impossible that in some clans in seeing what happened to Clan Smoke Jaguar,from units from the Inner Sphere. That the wardens that have lived in the Crusader Clans might decide to defect and make their own Smaller Clans to carry on the Warden Ideal. I believe that Clan Nova Cat did just that. Now I understand it is not canon that others did the same, but I think it is logical.
Also there could also be groups in the Inner Sphere that seeing how the Clan Invasion went that might believe they are right. Then decide to create their own Clan and also adopt Clan Laws,of course this is also not canon, So it seems to me that if you go solely by canon,you would be limiting the game severely. Is that what we all really want,to throw away the creativeness that we all have within ourselves?
Is it so impossible? No (though remember that at this timeline (3050) the examples you give are in the future).
Can you claim that it happened (apart from the instances explicitly recorded in the canon) and remain consistent with the BTverse? No. The BTverse has a very explicitly defined list of Clans. Yes this list changes as time goes by, but it changes in a very explicitly defined way.
You want to play a Clan? Pick one of the canon Clans that's available in whichever timeline you're playing.
Don't like that option? Play as a 'faction' within a Clan. There are a number of canon examples of these (some of which are quite fleshed out, others merely a reference), but there's not a definitive list (unlike the list of Clans), so there's quite a bit of flexibility available to you in developing your RP. It could be a unit, a Kindraa, a Khanate, a Great Cloister, etc.
Want to be completely independent of a canon faction? Well then play as a Merc or Pirate unit. There's no definitive (or even remotely comprehensive) list of these, so again, you've got quite a bit of flexibility.
TL;DR: You want to call yourself a Clan (not just as part of one of the canon Clans)? Play as a canon Clan.