Modo44, on 23 February 2014 - 03:37 AM, said:
Using the keyboard, you instantly set the desired speed, and always turn the legs at their maximum speed. To achieve the same using a joystick, you would need to make it silly sensitive, to the point of losing the fluidity it naturally allows. I will not explain why reaction speed may be preferred to precision in a FPS.
Incorrect. The opposite is in fact true.
Keyboard throttle control is relative.
Analog throttle control is absolute.
From standstill, hold the "speed up" key. How quickly is the throttle set to max speed (Not how long does it take to reach full speed, how long until the ghost indicator hits the top)
Now repeat with analog input - push the stick/throttle full forwards, the throttle is set to full speed *instantly*.
Best controls for MWO are:
1) Mouse aim. All other aim methods suck until PGI sort out Absolute stick aiming (They tried but got it horribly, horribly wrong. Avoid until if / when they fix it).
2) Analog throttle / steering.
Many choices here.
The throttle unit from a Thrustmaster T-Flight Hotas X is very cheap and the best ergonomically for MWO because the "rudder rocker" is better placed than the only other stick that has one (Saitek X45), and it is way way cheaper.
The thumbstick on a logitech G13 is GREAT for throttle. I use the W and S keys normally (Well, G4 and G11 they are called on my G13, but they are in the same position as A and S), but when edge-sniping, I use the analog throttle for very fine control.
Be aware however, that having throttle and leg turn on the same object (eg on the x and y axis of the same stick) DOES NOT WORK PROPERLY. You get "Bleed through" - when you mean to only turn, you change speed. When you mean to only change speed, you turn. ie it is not possible to move the same object precisely in only one axis - you will always unintentionally move in the other axis a little
Therefore, you want TWO SEPARATE controls for throttle and leg turn. This is why the Hotas X throttle unit is great - you get no bleedthrough as the throttle and rudder and totally independent of each other.
Also it is NOT POSSIBLE to get proper output from a joypad thumbstick for two axes because joypad thumbsticks have a "round aperture". That is to say, the range of motion is round, not square like a normal PC joystick. It is thus impossible to hit full right and full up at the same time. In fact, if at full right, you cannot move the stick up AT ALL.