200 public matches in my triple-PPC Awesome convinced me that the Awesome is non-viable in the public queue. Even post-buff, I still consider them unplayable in public games. Sure, I've gotten 6-kill, 800+ damage matches in the thing, on rare occasions, but occasional exceptional matches do not mean that it's a good 'mech.
The biggest problem isn't the hitboxes. Although the 'mech is oversized, it's pretty good at spreading the damage with torso twisting. The big problem is the low weapon mounts. A good 'mech will have jump jets or else high weapon mounts in order to be reasonably viable. With neither, you're going to be outclassed at direct fire, in general.
The Awesome is my favorite assault in the game, so it's a shame that it's always going to be second-rate at best. But that's how it is. Respect to the Awesome pilots who, despite its underdogginess, rock out the triple-PPC. I finally had to give up on trying that in public (mis)matches -- the new quirks definitely help, but not enough to save it from being put into a mechbay full of mothballs.
Compare:
AWS-9M, 3x PPC + 1x MPL, STD 315
TBR-S, 3x cERPPC + 2x JJ
(this is a stupid build, since it's quite inferior to the 2x cERPPC + 1x cGauss build, but even this 3x cERPPC thing does the Awesome's job better than the Awesome does)
AWS-9M, 3x PPC + 1x MPL + XL 375
Yes, the Timberwolf runs a bit hotter. No, that isn't going to let the Awesome match its general performance. That silly T-wolf build has longer range, no minimum range,
jump jets, faster speed, better maneuverability, and effectively more survivability. Oh, and some extra splash damage thrown in (which, according to Smurphy's weaponlab, gives the triple-ERPPC T-wolf better DPS
and better sustainable DPS than the triple-PPC Awesome -- although that is a splashy bonus, and I don't know if Smurphy's is taking the Awesome's heat quirks into account). It also doesn't take up an assault slot in the group. The only significant downside is that the cERPPCs are hotter than PPCs. That isn't gonna make up for the rest.
By the way, even the poor Thor is arguably better at the three-PPC thing than the Awesome; although the Thor will be running much hotter, it has a better armor-to-hitbox ratio, goes faster, and has loads of jump jets with which to better utilize that ghosty toasty Alpha. Farewell, invisiwalls, for I have slipped the surly bonds of dirt! Behold:
SMN-D, 3x cERPPC + 5x JJ
(also a fairly stupid build, I'd say)
Edited by Carl Avery, 02 August 2014 - 12:43 PM.