First impressions after a few games:
It's not a great 'Mech by any standard. It's not as bad as I was afraid it could be, and I actually pulled down some pretty nice scores with it a few times, but most of the tricks used for other IS lights just do not apply to this one. The PPC quirks are nice on the 10K and 9R; haven't tried the 8Z yet so I can't speak to how well it'll do with the lasers.
IMO what really hurts this chassis are those damned pauldrons on the shoulders. They make a 'Mech that's already large for its weight class even easier to hit, and the fact that the right arm is already huge doesn't help at all. Just eyeballing it, the frontal profile of that arm on the 9R with all its hardpoints filled is the same size as if not slightly larger than the CT. The low top speed is not a problem at all compared to the atrociously large hitboxes and incredibly low-slung weapons. Right now, the Panther is a full head taller than the Firestarter, yet its gun arm sits below where the FS9's arms do... and the Panther is not protected by speed or buggy hit detection. Damage spreading is far more critical to this chassis than any other light.
So far I've found that my decision to avoid dual ER/PPC builds was the right one. I'm doing fairly well protecting the gun arm- I only lost it before I died twice- but it is still a major vulnerability of the chassis, and I got a lot more use out of the SRMs and lasers than I expected to. Most of my kills were with those instead of the ER/PPC, which might just come down to my having loads more trigger time with those weapons.
If this were a medium, I'd say it could benefit from a STD to use that gigantic left side as a shield, but the spare tonnage just isn't there to make STD viable. I'm sure
somebody could pull it off, and I'd love to see the build, but I am not that somebody. I am, however, going to be adding more armor to my left arm to offset the general squishiness of the right.
All that sounds pretty harsh, but I'm actually enjoying the hell out of the Panthers. They're challenging (unlike a certain overgunned 35-tonner we all know) and utterly unique among IS lights. I'm not breaking even in them yet, but I think I'll be able to once they're elited, and then I see them becoming regulars in my rotation. I don't think I'll be selling any after all.
Edited by PS WrathOfDeadguy, 17 February 2015 - 03:47 PM.