csebal, on 18 June 2018 - 09:53 AM, said:
The problem:
- Group Queues are borked. There is no MM to speak of, so a bunch of casual joes can end up playing a well organized group of seasoned veterans. Since neither of the joes signed up to be **** victims, they will just not play GQ.
- Solaris Duos are the next option, but joe and joe will quickly realize, that it is a very different game, where the range of viable builds are vastly different than what can be used in the regular game AND they will also find themselves *****, because the few who keep playing solaris duos have become extremely proficient at it, and poor joe has neither the knowledge nor the practice to really compete on their level.
- Fed up with not being able to play together, they try syncdropping, and it works every now and then, but is unreliable and more hassle than what it is worth, so our casual joes just find themselves moving on to a different game.
The solution:
- The solo queue could be opened up for small groups, with the following criteria (or a similar set)
--> mechs in the group would have to be matched into the game individually, to not overcomplicate the MM and also to encourage diverse group setups. So finding a match with two assaults would be really hard, if everyone else also wants to play assaults, but a single assault and a single heavy would not be harder than two solo players queuing at the same time, given both have equal popularity.
--> the group would be bracketed according to the highest tier player, so if joe1 is tier 3 and joe2 is tier 5, then they would play according to a tier 3 bracket.
--> the number of groups on each side would be limited, but has to be equal
--> the tier difference restriction would never (or only as a last resort) be lifted for groups, regardless other MM restrictions being relaxed to avoid the edge cases where tier 1 players in groups can be matched against tier 4 or 5 players.
The drawbacks:
- in the extreme cases, when at odd hours very good players are bracketed with very weak one, it would be possible that two tier 1 players are matched against two tier 3 players with the rest of the teams also made up of tier 1-3 players. MM can try to compensate for this by allocating more stronger players on the other side to balance.
- wait times for groups could be longer due to the extra restrictions around matching groups.
The advantages:
- overall small group experience starts to exist (currently there is none)
- group play would see less outliers who have no clue about the game and tought it is a good idea to enter GP in two light mechs
- solo play could see more players, as people would be inclined to try and convince their friends to play with them once again.
We are at a point, where if my friend comes to also play MWO, I just tell him to play solo, as I cannot be convinced to play GQ. If small groups would be a thing, I could tell them to come play with me instead of telling them to not bother.
I myself would not mind waiting for the MM to find me a properly matched small group to play against, if that would mean a semblance of a fairly balanced match where I can play with friends. Currently I have no such option at all, so any option would be an improvement really.
If as you say "Group Queues are borked", then I think the most logical course of action is to actually fix them.
Your proposed solution -- changing the solo queue matchmaker to include duos -- just creates potentially more problems while not actually doing anything to fix the original one. In other words, you're telling people to fix something by "fixing" something else entirely.
csebal, on 18 June 2018 - 09:53 AM, said:
"Change can be frightening, and the temptation is often to resist it. But change almost always provides opportunities - to learn new things, to rethink tired processes, and to improve the way we work." - Klaus Schwab
Given that your solution above completely skirts the original problem, the quote is totally irrelevant.
“TACKLE the ROOT CAUSE not the EFFECT.” ― Haresh Sippy
Haipyng, on 18 June 2018 - 11:25 AM, said:
Heck, the "solution" of allowing 2s in the solo queue is even worse than a band-aid!
a le Roi, on 18 June 2018 - 12:00 PM, said:
If the problem is the group queue then ******* fix the group queue.
A good place to start is to allow solos into the queue.
Edited by Mystere, 18 June 2018 - 01:05 PM.