Posted 25 May 2013 - 07:41 PM
Hey everybody, I figured I'd weigh in on this because my unit encountered this several times today. If I am correct, ultimately we won 4-2 from our random encounters and in the first one, we had never seen it before.
However, this is insanely powerful, largely not because Streaks are OP (I don't think they are) but rather, when 8 people are using them, that's so much focus fire (that homes) it's devastating. I cannot stress enough that while we beat this, we only did so by exploiting the fact that in order to maximize the focus fire, no lights were in the enemy group to defend their base.
I do not, in fact, believe there is anything we could do to beat this in a straight up fight. However, again, the results were skewed by the lack of lights: 8 Highlander packing regular weapons would have a similar hard-to-beat effect, if they were willing to sacrifice scouts to do so, to be entirely honest. It would require more gunnery skill per-pilot to achieve that kind of "loss less" damage though, which is hard to replicate.
Long story short.. I don't know how to feel about this. I don't believe Streaks are OP even after witnessing this, but they are definitely something to take very seriously and if they're allowed to reach "critical mass" in a swarm, they go from dangerous to "HOLY HELL" really fast.
I don't mind anyone trying new tactics - if something really is broken, it should positively be brought to the light like that. A few of us Aces in Living Legends went around in LPL boat tanks for a week to help push re-balancing and it worked. I found every one of our fights an interesting learning experience and they gave me some things to think about.
If I sound critical here, it's just a frank discussion of your tactic and nothing personal, just making that clear. Again it's a hard one to really judge, because it does feel overpowered but I cannot in good conscience call it overpowered if we beat it most of the time. I think more controlled splatcat testing should come from this, though, as it's very very devastating at the very least.
Anyway, good games guys!