Khobai, on 21 December 2014 - 03:28 PM, said:
Not seeing how the Hellbringer is in a higher tier than the Timberwolf.
Timberwolf should get Tier 1 quirks, -1 for JJs
Hellbringer should get Tier 2 quirks, -1 for ECM, and +2 for no ES/FF
Summoner should get Tier 3 quirks -1 for JJs, and +1 for no ES
Because of omnipod swapping I dont think most clan mechs are worse than tier 3. Although maybe the clan lights are bad enough to be tier 4 or tier 5.
T1 quirks? you know that means it gets 0 quirks right? You do see the fact no one uses Timberwolf S side torsos? or the fact the ballistics arm is rarely used or ballistic CT / ST's.... or the Missiles...
It's a T2 or 3. (T3 quirks for missile and/or ballistics, T2-ish for energy... not in depth though, just something that makes it not able to be out done by a locust 1V in a range fight)
Also -1 quirk for having jumpjets? That'll punish the people who actually use jumpjets on a timberwolf... because jumpjets itself is the reason no one uses the Timberwolf S CT or ST's.... Punishing people for using the worst timberwolf variant in game just because jumpjets isn't the best balance idea i've heard...
T2 quirks for hellbringer? the hellbringer has no ES or FF... the summoner at least gets FF... I think the hellbringer will be on par with the Summoner. and if ECM torso is equiped then that torso provides less quirks or not as strong quirks.
(making it T2 will punish the people who will actually not use the ECM)
Summoner is equal or worse with the thunderbolt before quirks. It has FF instead of ES or both, it has forced jumpjets, if you want to run missiles and a ballistic (lets say stock prime) you got a 35 alpha... compaired to the firestarter-A 8 SPL 32 damage per alpha....
I think summoners would be a T4 mech.
Also note... There will be the Couldron-born coming in 2 years or less (less = it was only seen due to being a garrison / second line mech... it was only ever seen after the clans got there ass wiped. which is happening now... timeline wise technically supports the rapid CW progress).
Couldron Born for you who do not know what it is... is basicly a slightly lighter timberwolf with no jumpjets.
But can have duel Ballistic arms (1 B each), Duel energy arms (2+ E each), duel missile hardpoint torsos (1 to 2 M each), and some of those torsos also have an energy hardpoint...
Also has a low profile with all weapons above or equal to the main body/ cockpit...
This has everything 'OP' from the stormcrow and timberwolf wrapped in 1 package. It also has amazing pod space too...
Duel Guass + er ppc or 4 LRM 15 and/or 10's, etc can be done on it. If the timberwolf is a T0 mech then what the hell would this thing be?
Also i think the direwolf is around T3 to 4, Warhawk is between T3 to 5 (thunderbolt 9S atm can spew more ER PPC's then 2 Warhawks with nothing but 4 ER PPC's or 3 ER PPC's (waste of tonnage, you do not have enough tons to fill the whole mech up with heatsinks)... also the awesome also out peforms this warhawk but not as much.
Nova can be somewhere around T3 to 5 (hunchback 4P... unlike the nova, it doesn't get a penalty for boating medium lasers, it actually got buffs!...). Also jumpjet forced mech. And wide base too.
Mist lynx easily a T4 to 5 mech (due to med las situation).
Stormcrow could be a solid T3 (I point to my missile and ballistics discussion again.. on top of that but the laser builds are to hot to reliably do... the most popular I've seen are like 1 er large laser and 6 small lasers... I can do the same thing on a cicada with 1 less small laser and more speed and be colder...)
But this is just my opinions... so many variables with clans... but I think that the not popular parts of a mech should get a buffing out. ie energy nova's, ballistic and missile ice ferrets, timberwolfs, stormcrows, etc....
YueFei, on 10 January 2015 - 01:54 AM, said:
Sustained DPS would be such an important stat if mechs just ran around in the open with no cover blasting each other non-stop.
But that's not how mechs fight.
It's not a matter of pilot skill here. Bishop is a better player than I am. I've seen him play. And he's not getting better results out of the Summoner than I'm getting from my Hunchback. The Summoner needs buffs. I'm not saying this from selfishness, I don't even own *any* Clan mechs at all. I've fought against Summoners, and they ought to walk all over me and piss in my cereal, but they don't.
You know what does run me over and spit on the corpse? Stormcrows. Timberwolves. Yeah.
DPS is quite important in brawling situations and some snipping situations...
DPS is the main reason the thunderbolt is superior to the warhawk, direwolf, awesome, or atlas PPC / ER PPC builds.