Saber Avalon, on 10 June 2014 - 11:17 AM, said:
That being said, in lore, the Clans never made such bans during trials. You were allowed to use everything at the Clan's disposal. Now, given that this is the game and things are a bit different, you want to limit the cheese builds such as the AC40 to test how they pilot a mech. I would understand streaks if they still only went for the CT like in days of old but now each missile has a random target location. Sure, you do not have to aim them but they are not directing damage to a single location. You are not going to kill someone, with streaks, very fast. Non streaks, although manually aimed, can put most of their missiles into the same location. Streaks are not the feared OP weapon of old.
I am somewhat surprised by the quad AC5 restriction as well. Yes, it is high dps but you still have to land multiple shots and there are sacrifices made to make that build. Mobility and range will kill it. I just noticed you said UAC, same limitations exist but now they have 4 tons less ammo to play with and a jam mechanic to deal with. I do not know, to me a clan warrior should not be concerned with what he faces in battle. If someone needs an AC40 to win, then it will show and a skilled pilot would take them down with another build. Curious you did not mention dual gauss or PPC/meta builds. That being said, my favorite build runs MLs, standard SRMs, and an AC10.
I suppose you would want to limit the skilled players from using cheese builds, but then, they are already skilled.
The problem is we (and I am including my Ghost Bears as well in this) conduct augmented Trials as if they were unaugmented with the two opponents right next to each other. In the lore it was not so. The two contestants had to find each other. So bringing a double AC20 would be advantageous to one pilot seeing as his opponent is right there. What is he had to find him though? What if the CoE was a huge area & his opponent had longer range weapons? He might get his AC20s stripped, he might have the AC ammo destroyed or he might even get killed before he could even get in range to use the double AC20s. It would change how he fights.
The same holds true for Streaks. Sure you can lock on at 1000m & even fire them, but they will only hit a target at 270m or less.
I think we (all the Clans) need to rethink how we conduct Trials.
The definition of a Circle of Equals is:
Quote
The area in which a trial takes place is known as the Circle of Equals. It ranges in size from a few dozen feet for personal combat to tens of miles for large-scale trials. Though traditionally a circle, the area can be any shape.
Edited by Jaroth Corbett, 11 June 2014 - 01:31 PM.